In a season where the Sydney Sixers’ batting unit collectively faltered, the spotlight has fallen disproportionately on one man: Babar Azam. The Pakistan star, signed amid high expectations for Big Bash League 15, endured a modest run of form during the final stretch of the tournament. Yet the intensity of criticism directed at him—particularly from sections of the Australian cricket media—has raised questions about selective scrutiny and the narratives that shape modern cricket discourse.
Across the Sixers’ top order, inconsistency became a defining theme. Senior players, including captain Moises Henriques, struggled to provide stability in key matches. Strike rates dipped, partnerships failed to materialize, and the team often relied on its bowlers to remain competitive. Despite this collective downturn, commentary in the lead‑up to the finals increasingly centered on Babar’s place in the XI, with some pundits like Mark Waugh openly suggesting he be dropped.
Observers noted that the tone of this criticism felt disproportionate. Babar’s early contributions in the tournament were steady, if not explosive, and his role as an anchor was consistent with the Sixers’ tactical approach. Yet once he registered a couple of low scores, the narrative shifted sharply. Headlines questioned his adaptability, his intent, and even his suitability for the league—scrutiny that was not equally applied to other underperforming teammates.
The conversation escalated further on social media, where comparisons between Babar Azam and Virat Kohli—already a staple of cricket fandom—took on a more heated dimension. Some online voices, particularly from highly partisan corners of the cricket community, amplified criticism of Babar in ways that seemed less about BBL form and more about long‑standing rivalry narratives. For Indian Fans, debating Babar is basically debating Kohli’s legacy by proxy.
A striking twist in this digital storm has been the participation of some Pakistani content creators themselves. In an era where social media algorithms reward controversy, several Pakistani YouTubers and Facebook page owners have discovered that anti‑Babar content attracts massive engagement from Indian audiences. With India’s enormous cricket‑viewing population, even a mildly provocative headline can generate hundreds of thousands of views. As a result, criticism of Babar is sometimes amplified not out of sporting analysis, but out of a calculated attempt to tap into cross‑border traffic and monetize the rivalry. This dynamic has blurred the line between genuine critique and engagement‑driven sensationalism.
Even major cricket platforms like cricinfo, which is primarily managed by Indian executives out of Bangalore and has a large South Asian readership, adopted a tone that many fans felt was unnecessarily harsh, posting multiple ridiculing articles regarding Babar Azam on January 22nd, 2026 hence further confirming that Babar Azam hits a nerve in Indian cricket fandom in a way very few Pakistani players do. Analysts point out that such reactions reflect a broader trend: star players from the subcontinent often face polarized commentary that goes beyond performance metrics. Babar, as Pakistan’s most prominent modern batter and a global figure, naturally attracts attention. But the speed with which criticism escalated—especially when other Sixers batters posted similar or worse numbers—has prompted debate about fairness and objectivity in cricket coverage.
Inside the Sixers camp, the messaging remained calm. Coaches emphasized that form fluctuations are part of franchise cricket and reiterated their confidence in Babar’s class and experience. Teammates publicly backed him, noting that the entire batting group shared responsibility for the team’s inconsistent totals.
As the finals approached, the noise around Babar’s place in the side became a storyline of its own. Whether driven by media pressure, fan rivalry, or the economics of online engagement, the scrutiny highlighted how star players can become lightning rods in moments of collective struggle.
For Babar Azam, the BBL15 campaign may not be remembered for runs scored, but it will likely be remembered for the intensity of the spotlight he carried—one that often seemed heavier than the numbers alone could justify.
American Muslims 